Hello, I turned in my application already and had the same problem with not having enough forms for all of my extracurriculars. I play 4 varsity sports as a captain along with other academic extracurriculars, so I faced the exact same issue as you did. I contacted the USAFA admissions team about this, and received a reply that told me to list my highest achievement in each sport, then detail my other achievement in said sport in the “additional information” section. For example, for football I created one form as a varsity captain in 11th grade then detailed that I was a varsity lettering player in 9th-11th grade. I did this for all of my sports. I even emailed a member of the admissions team that I have had previous communications with to make sure that this was acceptable, and they told me that this would work perfectly. They also mentioned that they would bring up this conflict to the admissions team to see if it might be resolved in the coming admissions cycle for the class of 2026. If you have any questions don’t hesitate to ask me, I would be happy to clear up any confusion that my description may have brought you. Good luck and I hope to see you next summer at USAFA!